Skip to the main content

Review guidelines

A review serves the next person best when it comes from your own experience, gives particulars and treats people fairly. The same rules hold for every reviewer and every business.

A review worth leaving

  • You were there. The purchase, the booking, the job or the quote was yours, and not too long ago: within the last few years or so.
  • It has particulars. What did you buy, or what was done? Was the final price the one you were quoted? Did it arrive, or get finished, when promised? If something went wrong, how was it handled? Details serve the next customer far better than adjectives.
  • It is fair. Say what happened and how you were treated. Hold strong views if you like; leave the insults out.
  • It has room to say something. Between 40 and 3,000 characters.

What we leave out

  • Anything written by the company’s own people: its staff, their relatives, anyone it pays, or the same from a competitor.
  • Reviews that were bought, whether with money, a discount, a free gift, a raffle ticket or any other reward.
  • Reviews that belong elsewhere: about another company altogether, or about a product’s manufacturer, a seller on some marketplace or the payment processor, and not the business on this page.
  • More than one review from you about the same company in any thirty days.
  • Links, phone numbers and email addresses, along with a staff member’s full name or any other way of reaching them.
  • Anything hostile or explicit: threats, harassment, hateful language, swearing aimed at a person, sexual material.
  • Borrowed words: passages copied from another source, or text an AI tool produced in place of your own account.
  • Accusing anyone of a crime. Take that to the authorities; telling what happened to you is still welcome.

When businesses ask for reviews

We are glad when a business invites all of its customers to write a review. What it may not do is:

  • Hand out rewards of any kind for reviews, or save them for the glowing ones.
  • Seek out only the customers it expects to be pleased, or discourage the disappointed ones from writing.
  • Post reviews of its own business or of a competitor, or arrange for workers, family or an outside agency to post them.
  • Lean on a reviewer, or threaten one, to change a review or take it down.

These limits come from the US Federal Trade Commission’s rule on consumer reviews and testimonials, 16 CFR Part 465. A review won by ignoring them comes down.

Asking us to look again

Every review written on Lantern is read by a moderator before it is published, and when one is turned down we note why. If you believe we decided wrongly, write to us with the company’s name and the email address you used, and we will take a second look.