From draft to published
When someone writes a review here, it waits, marked pending, until a moderator has read it against our review guidelines. The moderator then publishes it or turns it down. Until it is published, a review is not shown on the company’s page and does not touch its score.
What the moderator looks for:
- That it tells of a real, first-hand dealing with this company: something ordered, booked, visited or quoted.
- Whether anything must be cut: a link or phone number, personal details about a member of staff, a threat, hate speech.
- Signs of one person writing again and again, or of reviews written by the company’s own staff or its competitors.
- The pace: one review per company from each person, every thirty days.
The company concerned is free to reply to any review, where everyone can read the reply. Editing, hiding and deleting are not open to it, and payment buys no different treatment. A one-star review travels the same road to publication as a five-star one.
Arriving at a score
Take the star ratings of every published review, add them together and divide by how many there are, rounded to one decimal place: that is the company’s score. We do not estimate it, nobody’s payment weighs on it, and no one nudges it by hand.
Until a company has five published reviews, its score is shown in grey and marked “Early days”, since a few reviews can tip it either way. From then on, the score takes the color of its band:
| Word | Average | Shown as |
|---|---|---|
| Wonderful | 4.5 – 5.0 | 4.7 |
| Pleasant | 4.0 – 4.4 | 4.2 |
| Ordinary | 3.0 – 3.9 | 3.4 |
| Disappointing | 2.0 – 2.9 | 2.5 |
| Regrettable | under 2.0 | 1.6 |
When selling and servicing differ
Each reviewer tells us what kind of dealing it was: a purchase, a question or a quote, or a service. Once enough of them have answered, the page shows one score for sales and another for service, since a business can sell well and repair badly, or the other way round.
Four details, two questions
Reviewers may also score four details (whether the business was upfront and easy to reach, the cost and any extras, how smoothly things went, and what they got in the end) and answer two questions about the bill: “When you paid, was it the figure you were first given?” and “Was anything added to the bill that nobody mentioned?” None of these is shown until five customers have answered it.
Putting a list in order
When a list is sorted by rating, its order also weighs how many reviews each company has, so a newcomer with three perfect reviews does not leap ahead of a business with forty excellent ones. We start every company with five imagined reviews of 3.5 stars each; as its real reviews accumulate, they draw its standing toward its true average:
standing = (3.5 × 5 + every star awarded) ÷ (5 + reviews published)
Remember that the ranking only arranges lists. On the company’s own page, the number you see is always the straightforward, unweighted average.
Three ways a review arrives
- Written on Lantern by the customer: typed here, on this site, by the person it happened to.
- Written on the company's own feedback form: the company asked its own customers for feedback and passed their answers on to us. We never accept feedback that the company chose, edited or paid for.
- Brought across from another platform: the customer wrote it on a different review site first, and it appears here unaltered.
About the listings
We put each listing together from business records that we collect and then check: its name and street address, its phone number and its website. When a company shuts its doors, or a listing can no longer be confirmed, the listing is hidden, never deleted, and every review written about it is kept.
Claiming a listing is free for the company it describes. It brings the right to fix the details and to reply to customers, and it leaves the score untouched.
If a review seems wrong
Beneath each review is a Report link. Use it when a review breaks our guidelines, describes a different company, or does not seem genuine to you. A moderator reads every report, then removes the review, leaves it up, or asks the reviewer for more detail. While we look into it, the review stays where it is.